New York Themed Gifts – The Best Guide for NYC Lovers

November 29, 2025November 30, 2025 shop

New York has a way of stealing your heart ❤️🥹
The skyline, the energy, the feeling that you always belonged here. And even after living in NYC for almost 20 years, I still get that unmistakable “I miss New York” feeling every time I travel… so trust me, I HEAR YOU.

If you’re searching for New York themed gifts, this guide brings that magic straight to you.

This Best Guide for NYC Lovers Lovers is part of my Holiday Gifts To Give and Get series, ideal for anyone who dreams of New York, someone planning their first trip, someone who visited once and never got over it, or someone who lives here and is still in love with the city. It’s your go-to list for NYC themed gifts, New York inspired accessories, and the best NYC gift ideas that truly feel special.

WHO THIS GUIDE IS FOR:

• Anyone searching for New York themed gifts or NYC gift ideas.
• NYC lovers who miss the city and want New York inspired gifts that feel meaningful and brings that magic home.
• First-time visitors planning a trip and wanting NYC-themed items before they go.
• Locals who want NYC inspired accessories and unique New York gifts to celebrate their city.
• Holiday shoppers looking for thoughtful, city-inspired presents for NYC Lovers..

NYC-Themed Holiday Ornaments

A tiny dose of New York magic for the holidays. This adorable ornament set brings the city home with a yellow cab, Statue of Liberty, Macy’s, the iconic NYC apple, and more. Perfect for anyone who misses New York, dreams of New York, or wants a little NYC sparkle on their tree.

Best NYC Coffee Table Book for NY Lovers

This is my favorite New York coffee table book ever!!! Every page is full of beautiful NYC photography, cozy corners, brownstones, hidden gems… t’s the perfect NYC-themed gift for anyone who loves New York, misses New York, or dreams of walking these streets again.

Anthropologie Loulou Baker NYC watercolor playing cards featuring illustrated New York scenes.

NYC Watercolor Playing Cards

They are such a sweet, artistic gift for any New York lover. Every card is a tiny watercolor moment of the city – taxis, parks, bridges, little scenes that make you smile and instantly miss NYC. I love how charming and nostalgic they feel!!

Dear New York – A Heartfelt Book

Dear New York is a love letter to the city, full of powerful stories, raw emotion, and that unmistakable feeling you get when NYC becomes part of who you are. Brandon Stanton (the creator of Humans of New York!) captured the soul of NY in this book!

NYC Giant Coloring Poster

I actually gifted this to Luca for one of his birthdays… and then I stole it and colored the whole thing myself 😅 I’m obsessed. It’s such a beautiful, detailed New York map! Perfect anti-stress coloring that makes you feel inspired. And once you’re done coloring, it becomes the cutest NYC wall art. A total win.

Ceramic mug designed like the classic NYC Greek coffee cup with the “We Are Happy To Serve You” design.

NYC Greek Coffee Cup Ceramic Mug

This is such a beloved NYC staple. Old-school New Yorkers know this cup by heart. For decades, every diner, food cart, and corner bodega served coffee in this exact Greek “We Are Happy To Serve You” cup. The ceramic version is even better. It feels nostalgic, playful, and instantly transports you to New York City streets.

Macy’s Parade NYC Coffee Mug

This mug captures all the little NYC obsessions: taxis, pretzels, bagels, coffee cups, hot dogs… The bold stripes and the gold handle feels festive, playful, and instantly nostalgic.

Red and white illustrated NYC skyline poster with the phrase ‘New York Loves You’ in bold lettering

New York Loves You Wall Art

NYC lovers will melt over this one. A sweet, minimalist poster that brings that “New York loves you back” feeling straight into your home. Clean lines, bold red, and the classic skyline… perfect for anyone dreaming of the city or missing it like crazy.

Green-and-white striped rectangular pillow with an embroidered yellow NYC taxi and pink piping on the edges.

NYC Striped Taxi Accent Pillow

A charming little luxury for your sofa. Hand-beaded details. Bold NYC stripes. A joyful accent that instantly elevates any space. Add it to your home and feel that NYC magic every time you walk by.

Brooklyn Bridge Holiday Pillow

This Brooklyn Bridge Christmas pillow brings that magical winter-in-NYC feeling straight into your living room. Cozy, charming, and perfect for anyone who misses New York or wants to bring a slice of New York into the holidays home.

Anthropologie NYC bistro tile stoneware mug with New York subway tile design on a neutral background

The Cutest NYC Bistro Tile Mug

That classic subway-tile look feels so New York, and every sip gives you a little taste of the city. I love gifting this to friends. It’s affordable, stylish, and full of that timeless New York charm.

Vintage New York Mini Notebooks

These vintage-style NYC mini notebooks are such a nostalgic gift for anyone who loves New York. The retro illustrations are super adorable and they give instant “old New York” vibes. They’re tiny, lightweight, and perfect for jotting down ideas, travel notes, or daily thoughts. Perfect for writers & travelers!

Vintage New York City Magnets Set

They bring that nostalgic NYC charm straight into your kitchen – retro colors, iconic landmarks, and that dreamy old-New-York feeling we all love!

Kate Spade MetroCard Wallet

Since we’re all riding the NYC subway with “tap & go” now, the old MetroCard is becoming instantly nostalgic, and this Kate Spade gem feels like owning a tiny piece of New York history.
I love how fun, cute, and already collectible it is.
Slip it into your bag and carry a slice of the Big Apple wherever you go.

Beaded Big Apple Coasters

These hand-beaded NYC coasters feel like tiny pieces of art. Each one captures a different slice of the city. They instantly elevate any coffee table and make your home feel a little more New York. A small dose of Big Apple magic you can use every day.

1000-piece New Yorker puzzle featuring a snowy Carnegie Hall illustration on the box, warm lights and winter crowd.

The New Yorker Magazine Art Puzzle

The Carnegie Hall glow, the bundled-up crowd, the magic of winter in the city… this puzzle is such a perfect cozy-night-in gift for anyone who adores New York, winter rituals, and moments that slow you down in the prettiest way.

Rockefeller Center Holiday Poster

The Rockefeller Christmas tree, the ice rink, the skyscrapers… all beautifully illustrated in that dreamy winter glow. Perfect gift for anyone obsessed with New York, missing the magic, or counting the days until their next trip. Cozy, nostalgic, and instantly festive.

Illustrated 2026 NYC wall calendar with colorful city scenes, yellow taxis, and whimsical New York details by artist Michael Storring

NYC Illustrated 2026 Wall Calendar

A joyful year of NYC magic. Illustrated scenes filled with color, energy, and that unmistakable New York charm. Perfect for planners, dreamers, and anyone who loves keeping a little bit of the city on their wall.

I only shared some of my favorite New York City–themed gifts here. Save this post because I’ll keep updating it every time I discover something special.

If you want more gift ideas, head to my full New York City Gift Guide for 2025. It includes NYC lover gifts, travel essentials, cozy living favorites, winter must-haves, stocking stuffers, and so much more.

SAVE it for December and share it with the person you love shopping with.

CIAOOOOO!!!!

Disclosure: While I may receive a small commission — at no extra cost to you — when you shop through the links on VivereNewYork, I only recommend products I genuinely love and use.
You can click here to read more about our editorial guidelines. Thank you so much for supporting my work and helping me keep sharing insider tips like this one! 💜

Laura Giromini

Brooklynite from Italy with infectious energy, Laura is a marketing content creator for major brands, professional photographer and she enjoys travel writing… especially for this blog! She shares NYC insider tips, unique experiences, and travel guides to inspire you to go after your dreams, live in wonder, and turn everyday life into Wow Moments.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Meet Laura, the energy behind VivereNewYork.

Ciaooo! I’m Laura. Originally from Tuscany, I traveled all over Italy as an actor and dancer until I moved to NYC in 2007 to pursue my acting career. In 2009, I launched Vivere New York to inspire EVERYONE to get the best out of their experience in New York City by sharing my personal discoveries, insider tips, and passion for life.

Today, I’ve expanded my horizons, exploring bucket-list destinations, and I love creating itinerary-based guides so you have all the info you need to get the most out of your travels!

Through my photography and storytelling, I want to empower YOU to chase your dreams, romanticize the everyday, and create your own Wow Moments wherever life takes you.