Unique Gifts Under $25: The Perfect Stocking Stuffers

December 1, 2025December 15, 2025 shop

If you’re on the hunt for unique gifts under $25 that feel cute, clever, and a little magical… you’re in the right place.

I put this guide together for anyone who loves surprising people with tiny treasures that feel personal and full of love.

Consider this your Best Guide for small gifts under $25, cute stocking stuffers, adorable little treats, thoughtful minis, and those “OMG I love this” moments we all live for during the holidays.

This list is part of my Holiday Gifts To Give and Get series, and I’ll keep adding new finds every time something special pops up in my world. SAVE IT, come back to it, use it as your secret weapon when you want to make someone smile.

WHO THIS GUIDE IS FOR:

• Anyone searching for unique gifts under $25 or sweet stocking stuffer ideas
• Holiday shoppers wanting small gifts under $25 that feels cute and lovable
• People looking for cute stocking stuffers, funny stocking stuffers, or thoughtful mini gifts
• Anyone who loves little surprises that make the holidays feel even sweeter

Unique Gifts Under $25

Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm in Pink Sugar – vegan hydrating lip balm under $25

Pink Sugar Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm

Soft, glossy, sweet. This Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm is one of my go-to gifts under-$25 – hydrating, vegan, and the perfect sheer pink. It’s that tiny luxury everyone loves tossing in their bag. A dreamy stocking stuffer.

Bombas women’s fuzzy socks in Pink Sparkle – cozy winter socks under $25

Soft, Plush, Warm Bombas Fuzzy Socks

Soft, warm, and unbelievably cozy. These Bombas fuzzy socks feel like a hug for your feet – perfect under-$25 winter gift.

Soft Bamboo NYC Socks for Men

Soft, fun, and so New York. These bamboo NYC socks make the cutest under-$10 gift – comfy, lightweight, and covered in all the iconic little moments we love. Perfect for travelers, NYC lovers, or anyone who needs a tiny splash of city joy.

Reusable makeup remover cloths 6-pack in neutral colors – soft eco-friendly beauty gift under $20

Makeup Remover Cloths – Reusable 6-Pack

These reusable makeup remover cloths are a tiny beauty essential – soft, eco-friendly, and perfect for taking off makeup with just water. A practical under-$20 stocking stuffer that feels thoughtful, useful, and surprisingly luxe.

Collagen Sheet Mask Under $5

Such a good one. This Bio Collagen sheet mask gives instant glow!!! Hydrating, firming, and perfect for a quick at-home spa moment. A tiny under-$5 beauty treat that always feels luxe. Ideal for wellness lovers and stocking stuffers.

Snowman Figural Mug for Hot Cocoa Season

A cozy morning in a mug. This adorable snowman feels like Christmas cheer in your hands. Perfect for hot cocoa, coffee, or gifting someone who lives for holiday magic. Love a good mug that makes you smile every time.

Ski Lover Holiday Mug Gift

Thick, glossy stoneware, adorable après-ski illustrations, and that Anthro charm we all fall for. This mug is pure winter joy! It feels sturdy in your hands and makes every hot chocolate taste like a mini mountain escape. Perfect under-$25 treat for ski lovers, winter lovers, or anyone who needs a daily dose of cozy. (I got it for Luca 💙)

Striped red and pink matchbox with gold lettering ‘light my fire,’ filled with red and white matches

Small, Beautiful, and So Perfect for Candle Lovers

A tiny luxury that makes your candle rituals feel special. The design is gorgeous, and it instantly adds a touch of charm to any cozy moment. I love gifting these because they feel thoughtful, elevated, and just beautiful on a coffee table.

Tell Me More Conversation Game

A beautiful way to get closer to the people you love. This card game is filled with thoughtful prompts that spark real connection, laughter, and those late-night heart-to-hearts we all crave. Perfect under-$20 for date nights, family time, or holiday gatherings.

Small teal coin purse with retro platform shoes and text reading ‘If the shoe fits buy it

Funny Retro Coin Holder

Tiny, sassy, and perfect for gifting. This little Blue Q pouch cracks me up every time. It holds cards, coins, earbuds, anything tiny… and the retro shoe graphic is pure fun. A cute stocking stuffer that feels very “treat yourself” energy.

Vintage-Style Portable Bluetooth Speaker

Lightweight, portable, and cute enough to leave out as decor, it’s the perfect little gift for anyone who loves vintage vibes, cozy playlists, or stylish touches around the house. Pairs instantly with your phone, plays for hours, and makes every room feel warmer under-$20.

Super Cute Cherry Cloud Claw Clip

This one is ADORABLE. This cherry-print claw clip is the cutest under-$15 find – lightweight, recycled, and strong enough to hold hair all day.
A fun, stylish stocking stuffer that instantly adds charm to any look.

Burt’s Bees Mistletoe Kiss Holiday Gift Set with three tinted lip balms – natural hydrating lip color under $12

Burt’s Bees Mistletoe Kiss Gift Set

I love this one!!! These Burt’s Bees tinted balms give you that soft, natural color without needing makeup I always put it on to instantly feel “natural pretty”. Hydrating, flattering, and the perfect under-$12 stocking stuffer for everyday glow.

Minimalist Car Pine Scent Freshener

This clean pine scent is long-lasting, essential-oil based, and looks sleek on the dashboard. A perfect under-$20 stocking stuffer for anyone who loves a tidy, good-smelling car.

Heatless Curling Ribbon for Soft Satin Waves

So cute and so easy. This satin heatless curling set gives pretty, bouncy waves overnight – no heat, no damage. The satin keeps my hair frizz-free, smooth, and protected, and the tie-dye colors make it feel extra cute. A perfect under-$20 stocking stuffer for anyone who loves effortless beauty.

Mini Heart Waffle Maker

The quickest way to make breakfast feel special. This mini heart waffle maker is tiny, adorable, and creates the cutest waffles in minutes. Perfect stocking stuffer. Perfect gift. Perfect cozy winter morning vibe.

Williams Sonoma Peppermint Bark Meltaways in red holiday box with white chocolate peppermint pieces displayed in front

Peppermint Bark Gift Idea

What are the holidays without chocolate? These Peppermint Bark Meltawaysare too good!!! Creamy white chocolate, crunchy peppermint, that soft melt-on-your-tongue moment everyone raves about. They’re impossible to stop eating… and a perfect under-$20!.

The New Yorker Magazine Art Puzzle

The Carnegie Hall glow, the bundled-up crowd, the magic of winter in the city… this puzzle is such a perfect cozy-night-in gift for anyone who adores New York, winter rituals, and moments that slow you down in the prettiest way.

Vanilla Skin Mist, Warm & Spicy Winter Favorite

What are the holidays without chocolate? These Peppermint Bark Meltawaysare too good!!! Creamy white chocolate, crunchy peppermint, that soft melt-on-your-tongue moment everyone raves about. They’re impossible to stop eating… and a perfect under-$20!.

Cozy Conversation Starter for Friends & Family

The Hygge Game turns any evening into warm connection with thoughtful prompts that spark real conversation. Perfect for friends, family, date nights, or holiday gatherings. Perfect gift under-$20!.

The Cutest Personalized Book to Make Someone Feel Special

You fill in the prompts… and suddenly it becomes the most personal gift ever. It’s sweet, fun, intimate, emotional – all in the best way.

Save this guide! I update it every time I find something special ✨

And if you want even more ideas, head to my full New York City Gift Guide for 2025, or explore all my NYC gift lists here:
– SURVIVING WINTER MUST HAVES
– TRAVEL ESSENTIALS
– CREATOR MUST HAVES
– NYC LOVER GIFTS
– UNIQUE GIFTS UNDER $25
– WELLNESS, BEAUTY, & RITUALS
– EXPERIENCES TO GIVE (AND GET)
–STYLE & HOME

Disclosure: While I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you when you book through the links on VivereNewYork, I only recommend what I truly love (see our editorial guidelines). Thank you so much for supporting my work and helping me keep sharing insider tips like this one! by booking through VivereNewYork!!! 💜

Laura Giromini

Brooklynite from Italy with infectious energy, Laura is a marketing content creator for major brands, professional photographer and she enjoys travel writing… especially for this blog! She shares NYC insider tips, unique experiences, and travel guides to inspire you to go after your dreams, live in wonder, and turn everyday life into Wow Moments.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Meet Laura, the energy behind VivereNewYork.

Ciaooo! I’m Laura. Originally from Tuscany, I traveled all over Italy as an actor and dancer until I moved to NYC in 2007 to pursue my acting career. In 2009, I launched Vivere New York to inspire EVERYONE to get the best out of their experience in New York City by sharing my personal discoveries, insider tips, and passion for life.

Today, I’ve expanded my horizons, exploring bucket-list destinations, and I love creating itinerary-based guides so you have all the info you need to get the most out of your travels!

Through my photography and storytelling, I want to empower YOU to chase your dreams, romanticize the everyday, and create your own Wow Moments wherever life takes you.