When I got the invite from Visit PA to attend a 3-day trip in Gettysburg to discover the history and the ghosts of the city, I hesitated for a second and asked Luca if he was available to come with me. When he responded with a simple “Why not?”, I had no more excuses but to say yes. To be completely honest, I would have been terrified to go alone – lol!
What I loved most about our trip is the stories we heard and getting the chance to really step back into the past and relive history. I was also so pleasantly surprised by the city itself. Beyond its legendary haunted past, Gettysburg is expanding into such an incredible fall destination filled with gorgeous autumn foliage, apple picking, fantastic breweries, and delicious restaurants.

And that is just scratching the surface of what we experienced in only 3 days. We stayed right in the heart of it all at the historic Farnsworth House Inn, dined in a tavern built in 1776, and uncovered a side of Pennsylvania I am already itching to go back and explore more.
If you are thinking about planning a spooky, story-driven autumn getaway just a short drive from the city, here is the honest, inside look at our haunted weekend, and everything else this historic area has to offer right now.
Our 3-Day Gettysburg Itinerary at a Glance:
Day 1: Check in at the Farnsworth House Inn, dinner at Dobbin House Tavern, night ghost walk
Day 2: Eisenhower farm tour, lunch at Warehouse Gourmet in Hanover, Sign of the Horse Brewery, battlefield tour, dinner at Sign of the Buck
Day 3: Coffee at Waldo’s & Company, head home

📌 Disclosure: This trip was hosted by Visit PA. As always, every opinion is 100% mine. This post may also contain affiliate links, meaning I may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you book or buy through them. Learn more about our editorial guidelines.
Farnsworth House Inn Gettysburg: My Honest Review
Pulling up to 401 Baltimore Street, the history hits you immediately. The oldest part of the Farnsworth House Inn, a wooden section, dates back to around 1810, and the brick house you see from Baltimore Street was built in 1833. More rooms were added around the 1970s. If you walk around to the side, you can trace your fingers along the exterior brick and see over 100 bullet holes still visible from the battle, each one marked in white. Most were fired by Union soldiers on Cemetery Hill, aiming at Confederate sharpshooters hiding in the attic.
One of those sharpshooters is believed to have fired the shot that killed Jennie Wade, the only civilian killed during the Battle of Gettysburg. The house itself is named after Brigadier General Elon Farnsworth, who died leading a cavalry charge on July 3, 1863.
When it was time to check in, we picked our room keys right out of a jar, a fun touch that added to the anticipation. I’m not sure if they do it all the time or if they reserved this special treatment for us, since we were a group of seven journalists, writers, and creators. We ended up in the Bell Room, and with its Botticelli-style fresco wallpaper, it felt like a tiny nod to my Italian roots right there in Pennsylvania.
What It’s Really Like Inside the Rooms
Let’s be completely honest for a second: for the way I usually travel, I would never normally pick a hotel like this – lol. I like spaces that are neat, clean, bright, and organized. I spend most of my money on travel, from traveling overseas in business class to booking lovely stays with beautiful boho, modern, and pretty aesthetics.
The room was quite small, with no desk (which broke my heart a little, as I always love having a spot to sit down and work), and it was very, very dark – clearly styled that way to lean into the haunted and spooky vibe. Heavy, dark wooden furniture like a four-poster bed and an antique armoire dominate the space, and the walls are covered in dark, classical cherub and figure frescoes that are peeling in places, adding to the scary character of the house.


The bathroom, surprisingly, was almost as big as the bedroom itself! Styled like an antique Roman bath, it featured a faux-tin tile ceiling, exposed brick, a blue pedestal sink, potted plants on pillars, and even a large raised jet tub (which we didn’t use).
Because Luca and I are used to a king-size bed everywhere we go (from Brooklyn to upstate New York to our house in Italy), we didn’t love the full-size bed setup. And while I completely passed out and slept like a baby (giving away the fact that I didn’t have any ghostly encounters of my own!), poor Luca was hoping for a midnight visitor and didn’t experience anything either.
The Stories We Didn’t Expect: Breakfast with “Jeremy”
While flipping through the guest journals left in the rooms, we were so surprised to see how many people come back year after year. Some celebrating birthdays, anniversaries, and even honeymoons (!!!) writing excitedly about hearing ghosts or unexplainable noises.
Instead, the most amazing experience I had was over breakfast in the main building. When I asked our waitress what it’s really like working in a famously haunted hotel day in and day out, she smiled and told us she feels completely safe, mentioning that with all the steep historic stairs, she’s often felt herself tripping only to feel supported and caught by an unseen presence…!


Then, she shared a story that gave me immediate goosebumps. Years ago, when her daughter was 9 and legally blind with very thick glasses, she had to bring her along to work because she had no one else to watch her. Knowing she couldn’t afford to have anything broken, she sat her down and asked her not to touch a thing.
Suddenly, she heard a sound like a bouncing rubber ball. Rushing into the room, she watched in total disbelief as a ball bounced on the floor, hung suspended in the air for a second, and bounced back toward her daughter. When she asked what she was doing, her daughter replied, “I’m playing with my new friend Jeremy.”
She watched her legally blind daughter hug an invisible boy of similar height… supposedly Jeremy, the little boy whose spirit is said to haunt the house! Local legend says Jeremy was a young boy tragically struck by a horse-drawn carriage on Baltimore Street right outside in the 1800s, staying behind ever since as a gentle, playful spirit. To this day, whenever she visits her mom, her daughter still brings little gifts for him.
I truly felt Jeremy was in the room with us!!!
The Verdict on Farnsworth House
Do I believe the building is haunted? After hearing all those stories, I certainly wouldn’t rule it out! The history, the atmosphere, and the firsthand accounts from people who work there gave me goosebumps.
Would I personally choose a brighter, more comfortable, modern hotel next time? For my own sleep and workspace preferences, yes. Though I’m also happy we stepped out of our comfort zone to experience it firsthand. It was entirely peculiar, fascinating, and an unforgettable chapter of our Gettysburg trip.
📍 Farnsworth House Inn, 401 Baltimore Street, Gettysburg, PA.
Good to know: The inn has 12 rooms across the main house, garden and cottage, plus its own restaurant, tavern and ghost tours.
Dobbin House Tavern: Dinner in Gettysburg’s Oldest Building (1776)
After settling into our room at the Farnsworth House, we walked over for dinner at the Dobbin House Tavern, and it felt like stepping straight back into 1776. Built by Reverend Alexander Dobbin, it is the oldest standing structure in Gettysburg.
Over the centuries, it has been a family home, one of the first classical schools west of the Susquehanna River, a secret hiding place on the Underground Railroad, and a hospital for wounded soldiers after the Battle of Gettysburg.

The Springhouse Tavern downstairs, lit by candles and two glowing fireplaces, is cozy, historic, and atmospheric. The waitstaff wear period-accurate Colonial attire, serving meals on rustic pottery plates by candlelight. I ordered the Seafood Isabella, a house specialty featuring a delicious, decadent medley of scallops, shrimp, and crabmeat simmered in a delicate wine sauce with fresh vegetables, and I absolutely loved every single bite!
As we were all leaving the dining room together, Jay suddenly had to stop because his shoelaces had come undone. And then Bailey had to stop for the exact same reason! They both ALWAYS double-knot their shoes, so we thought it was a little odd, though nobody paid much attention to it.
Until a few minutes later, when our ghost tour guide told us about the little girl who supposedly haunts the Dobbin House…
📍 Dobbin House Tavern, 89 Steinwehr Avenue, Gettysburg, PA.
A Private Night Ghost Walk with Gettysburg Ghost Tours
With our bellies full and the sun completely down, we met up with our host from Gettysburg Ghost Tours for a private late-night walk through the historic district.
Dressed in a full 19th-century black period gown, our guide looked like she had stepped directly out of history, setting an incredible mood before we even took our first step. Gathering us together outside the stone walls of the Dobbin House complex, she explained the history of why we met at the tavern in the first place. She shared the story of Reverend Alexander Dobbin, a widower with 10 children, and his second wife, a widow with 9 children of her own, bringing 19 siblings to live together under one roof! Tragically, two of the children died of typhoid fever, including a young girl who, according to local legend, never really left the house.





Our host explained that this little girl still frequents the top floor of the house, often spotted peering out of the upper windows. Playful and mischievous, her absolute favorite thing in the world to do is untie people’s shoelaces!
And here’s a tip from our host: while ghost tours tend to book up quickly in October, especially around Halloween (which totally makes sense!), she suggested visiting around Easter instead. As she put it, the ghosts are there all year round!
So if you’re planning a Gettysburg getaway outside spooky season, don’t skip the ghost tour. The stories are just as fascinating in spring!
Ghost Stories & Photographing the Unexplained
As our guide led us through the quiet streets, she encouraged us to snap as many photos as possible, explaining that guests frequently capture unexplainable figures, light orbs, or mists on camera that aren’t visible to the naked eye. Along the way, she shared her own chilling personal encounters with Confederate apparitions, as well as stories passed down from previous tour guests who had experienced unexplainable moments in these very alleys.
We stopped near dark parlors and shadowy alleyways off Baltimore Street, holding up our phones to take pictures into the dim lighting.

You don’t need to believe in ghosts to enjoy a ghost tour in Gettysburg. In fact, I think it’s an absolute MUST! Between the fascinating Civil War history, the local legends, and walking through the same streets where everything happened, it’s such a memorable way to experience the town after dark.
One little heads-up: some local students apparently enjoy jumping out and screaming at ghost tour groups to scare them. We experienced it ourselves! Nothing dangerous, just a little annoying when you’re completely immersed in a story.
Still, I would absolutely do this again. The history alone makes it worth it!
Eisenhower Farm in Gettysburg: The Home They Always Dreamed Of
The next morning, we stepped into a completely different chapter of American history with a private tour of the Eisenhower National Historic Site, the former home of President Dwight D. Eisenhower and his wife, Mamie. And what a home!!!
Before becoming the 34th President of the United States, Dwight D. Eisenhower had already lived in Gettysburg. Back in 1918, during World War I, he was a young Army captain assigned to Camp Colt, a tank-training facility right on the Gettysburg battlefield, where he served as commander. His wife Mamie and their baby boy joined him, and the town became a meaningful part of their early married life.
Fast-forward more than 30 years. After a military career that took them around the world, and nearly 40 moves during their marriage, Dwight and Mamie were finally dreaming of settling down in Gettysburg, their very first place together.
In 1950, they found a beautiful 189-acre farm near the very battlefield where Dwight had once trained soldiers.
Our ranger told us that the farm was originally listed for $20,000, and when the owner discovered the buyer was none other than the famous World War II general Dwight D. Eisenhower, the price suddenly went UP!!! According to the National Park Service, they paid $44,000, and it became the only home Dwight and Mamie ever owned together.


While everyone assumed he was incredibly wealthy as a general, our ranger Conner explained that the success of his bestselling memoir, Crusade in Europe, actually helped him afford his dream home.
And here’s where life is always unpredictable… just when Dwight and Mamie thought they could finally settle down and enjoy retirement, President Harry Truman CALLED!!! The Korean War had begun, tensions between the United States and the Soviet Union were growing, and Truman wanted Eisenhower to return to military leadership as NATO’s first Supreme Allied Commander Europe.
As a man of service, clearly, Eisenhower said YES. So he left for Europe, putting their retirement dreams on hold…
In 1952, Eisenhower ran for president of the United States – AND WON – so it wasn’t until 1961, ELEVEN YEARS after buying their beloved farmhouse, that Dwight and Mamie finally got to retire there.
Can you imagine?! After spending decades moving around the world, they had finally found their HOME, only to wait another eleven years before they could truly settle into it. 🥹
Stepping Straight Into the 1950s
While Eisenhower’s career kept taking him away, Mamie took a very personal interest in decorating their home. Stepping inside feels like traveling straight back to the 1950s!
The 14-room farmhouse, rebuilt around part of the original house and finished in 1955, is filled with furniture, family photographs, personal belongings, and gifts from world leaders… and Mamie REALLY loved her pink!!! 💗



Her famous pink bathroom is just the beginning. From her towels to her personal accessories, she surrounded herself with her favorite color, which eventually became one of the most recognizable decorating trends of the 1950s.
A Presidential Home Filled With History
Eisenhower used the farm as a weekend escape from Washington, D.C., and welcomed important international leaders here, sometimes discussing world affairs in a much more relaxed setting than the White House, and in 1955, after suffering a heart attack, he even conducted presidential business from Gettysburg while recovering.
📍 Eisenhower National Historic Site, 250 Eisenhower Farm Road, Gettysburg, PA.
Good to know: Admission and ranger-led house tours are free. Tour schedules vary by season, so check the Eisenhower National Historic Site for current schedules before visiting.
Things to Do in Hanover, PA: A Small Town With So Much Going On!
We headed to nearby Hanover, Pennsylvania, just a short drive from Gettysburg, for lunch, followed by a brewery tour.
Known as the Snack Food Capital of the World, Hanover is home to some of America’s most famous snack brands, including Utz potato chips and Snyder’s of Hanover. What started as small family businesses making chips and pretzels (Utz began in 1921 in Bill and Salie Utz’s own kitchen!) grew into a major snack-food industry.
Hanover also has its own fascinating Civil War history (the Battle of Hanover was fought on June 30, 1863, the day before Gettysburg began!), and I was actually surprised to learn just how many festivals and activities they organize throughout the year!
From 2nd Saturdays, a monthly downtown celebration with special events at local businesses (an Oktoberfest bites & brews stroll in September, trick-or-treat in October!), to Oktoberfest and Christmas festivities, it feels like there’s ALWAYS something happening! We only spent a few hours here, and I already want to come back to experience more of it!
Good to know: Visit Main Street Hanover for downtown events, shopping, restaurants, and their interactive walking map.
Lunch at Warehouse Gourmet Bistro & Brewpub
Our first stop in Hanover was Warehouse Gourmet Bistro & Brewpub, a cozy, family-owned restaurant housed in a restored 1912 ribbon factory that was once an art studio, too. When we asked the owner what she recommended ordering, her answer genuinely made me smile.
“ANYTHING!!!” She explained that she takes so much pride in curating her menu that she wants every single dish to be delicious. So rather than recommending one particular item, she encouraged us to order whatever sounded good to us. I LOVED that.

I ordered the Goat Cheese Salad with apples, pecans, and honey balsamic vinaigrette, adding shrimp, and it was DELICIOUS!!!
📍 Warehouse Gourmet Bistro & Brewpub, 7 Pennsylvania Avenue, Hanover, PA.
Sign of the Horse Brewery: Craft Beer, Great Food & Local Passion
Our next stop was Sign of the Horse Brewery, where we got a private behind-the-scenes tour with Brad and Matt, two of the owners.
Before brewing beer professionally, Matt started homebrewing when he was around 21. He also worked in the culinary world, including at Cure, a restaurant in Pittsburgh, where he experimented with fermentation, charcuterie, and vinegar production.
As he walked us through the brewing equipment, he explained how different ingredients, fermentation techniques, and even bacteria influence the flavor of beer. Their brewing system can produce approximately 310 gallons of beer per batch, and we learned about everything from wild fermentation to seasonal Oktoberfest and pumpkin beers! 🍻



We tried a flight of FIVE different beers, paired with samples from their food menu. We were all still FULL from lunch, and yet I couldn’t stop eating, especially the Bang Bang Shrimp. TO DIE FOR!!! Put it on your must-visit list, trust me!
Fun fact: Founded in 2019, the brewery takes its name from the Sign of the Horse, one of Hanover’s first taverns. Thomas Jefferson spent the night there in May 1776, on his way to Philadelphia, just weeks before he wrote the Declaration of Independence. He even recorded what he paid for dinner and a bed in his account book!
Good to know: Sign of the Horse Brewery has locations in Hanover, Red Lion, and York. Check their website for current hours, menus, and beers on tap.
Gettysburg National Military Park: Where History Comes Alive
We then headed back to Gettysburg for a private guided tour of Gettysburg National Military Park… You can’t really understand the soul of Gettysburg unless you experience this. I HIGHLY recommend visiting!
The Battle of Gettysburg, fought July 1–3, 1863, was one of the bloodiest battles of the American Civil War and a major turning point in the conflict. Over three days, more than 51,000 soldiers were killed, wounded, captured, or reported missing.
It’s one thing to read about those numbers. It’s something completely different to stand where it all happened, and our guide made it feel SO REAL!!!



Becoming a Licensed Battlefield Guide at Gettysburg is EXTREMELY difficult! Candidates must pass a demanding examination and licensing process, which explains the extraordinary depth of knowledge our guide brought to the experience.
Ours was incredibly passionate about the battle. As he explained what happened during those three days, he would often CLOSE HIS EYES and speak as if he were actually witnessing the battle. I could almost SEE the soldiers marching across the fields, hear the cannons, and imagine the fear and uncertainty of those moments 🥹
We explored the battlefield by bus, stopping at historic sites including McPherson Ridge, where Union General John Buford’s cavalry fought to delay Confederate troops, and Seminary Ridge, where we learned why controlling the higher ground was so important.

One thing our guide kept coming back to was how close the Union came to losing, and that we could have ended up as TWO separate countries!
On July 1, the Union was LOSING. Confederate soldiers pushed them back through Gettysburg, and everything seemed to be falling apart. However, the Union soldiers managed to regroup on higher ground, reinforcements arrived, and they held their positions through two more days of brutal fighting.
Against the odds, they WON!!! That higher ground helped change the course of American history.

FUN FACT: Our guide was NOT impressed with Hollywood’s portrayals of the Civil War! 😂 He repeatedly complained that no movie had ever truly captured what those three days at Gettysburg were like.
We also stopped near the Virginia Memorial, where General Robert E. Lee is depicted on his horse, Traveller. Looking across the open fields toward the Union positions, we learned about Pickett’s Charge, the disastrous Confederate assault on July 3.
Good to know: We explored the battlefield by bus, but you can also discover it through guided car tours, walking tours, and even HORSEBACK RIDING!!!
Visit the Gettysburg National Military Park website for information about planning your visit and available tours.
Dinner at Sign of the Buck: A Different Side of Gettysburg
WHAT A DAY!!! And we ended it in the most beautiful way, with dinner at Sign of the Buck.
Located inside the historic Union Hotel, a tavern and hotel since 1804, this restaurant felt COMPLETELY different from everything else we’d experienced in Gettysburg!
After all the Civil War history, haunted houses, and old-fashioned taverns, we walked into a stylish, modern bistro with dark green walls, warm wood, beautiful lighting, and a gorgeous bar.

It honestly felt like stepping into one of those chic neighborhood restaurants I’d expect to find in Brooklyn… I LOVED discovering this side of Gettysburg!
Good to know: Sign of the Buck is located at 29 Chambersburg Street, right in downtown Gettysburg. Its seasonal menu showcases the best of Adams County, from fresh local produce to farm-raised meats.
One Last Gettysburg Surprise: Waldo’s & Company
We spent one more night at the Farnsworth House Inn, with “NO activities reported!” as they say (referring to paranormal activities).
The following morning, before heading home, we stopped for coffee and pastries at Waldo’s & Company… such a cool discovery!!!!
This place is a nonprofit creative space where local artists can work, exhibit and sell their art, share equipment, and teach workshops! Everyone is welcome to come in, grab a coffee, take a class, or simply enjoy the atmosphere.


Fun fact: There are NO fixed prices for the drinks! You donate what you wish, and your contribution helps support the artists and keep the space accessible. HOW COOL IS THAT?!
It reminded me of Williamsburg, Brooklyn, 15+ years ago, when artists, independent studios, and little creative spaces gave the neighborhood so much of its personality (before rising prices pushed many artists farther into Brooklyn and Queens).
What an unexpected way to end our Gettysburg getaway!!!
Good to know: Waldo’s & Company is at 17 Lincoln Square in downtown Gettysburg, downstairs: take the staircase inside the Lark shop, or use the back entrance on Race Horse Alley.
Plan Your Weekend in Gettysburg
Getting There
Gettysburg is about 3.5–4 hours by car from New York City, making it an easy weekend getaway!
We actually left Brooklyn on Friday night and used our Marriott Bonvoy points to spend the night at the Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Allentown West. This is one of our favorite road trip hacks! Instead of sitting in NYC traffic the next morning, we leave after dinner, drive for a couple of hours, and stop somewhere along the way.
That way, we wake up rested, avoid the worst of the traffic, and only have another couple of hours to drive before starting our adventure!
Where to Stay
We stayed two nights at the Farnsworth House Inn, right on Baltimore Street, walking distance from Dobbin House, the ghost tours and downtown. Book it if you love history and ghost stories and don’t mind a small, dark, antique room. If you need a desk, bright light and a king bed, choose a more modern hotel and come to the Farnsworth for dinner or a ghost tour instead.
When to Go
Fall is magical, with foliage, apple season and spooky season all at once. However, ghost tours book up fast in October, so reserve ahead. Our guide’s tip: come in spring, around Easter. As she put it, the ghosts are there all year round!
Gettysburg FAQ
Is Gettysburg haunted?
Gettysburg has a reputation as one of the most haunted towns in America, and almost every historic building has a ghost story. We didn’t see anything ourselves, however, between Jeremy at the Farnsworth House and the untied shoelaces at Dobbin House, the stories gave us goosebumps.
Can you stay overnight at the Farnsworth House?
Yes. The Farnsworth House Inn has 12 rooms across the main house, garden and cottage. We stayed in the Bell Room. The rooms are small, dark and antique, with full-size beds, perfect for the atmosphere but not for working.
How many days do you need in Gettysburg?
Three day felt perfect: one evening for dinner and a ghost walk, one full day for the Eisenhower farm, Hanover and the battlefield, and a slow coffee before heading home.
Good to Know Before You Go
- Eisenhower National Historic Site: Farmhouse tours are free, although access is seasonal. Check the National Park Service website for current tour schedules.
- Gettysburg Battlefield: Guided battlefield tours can be arranged through the Gettysburg Foundation. Booking ahead is recommended.
- Hanover, PA: Just a 30-minute drive from Gettysburg, Hanover is definitely worth the detour, especially for craft beer and delicious food at Sign of the Horse Brewery!
Is Gettysburg Worth Visiting? ABSOLUTELY!!!
I came to Gettysburg expecting history, haunted houses, and ghost stories… From sleeping in one of Gettysburg’s famously haunted inns to exploring the battlefield, discovering Hanover’s food scene, and finding an underground creative community, this weekend was full of surprises.
And the best part? Gettysburg is only about 3.5–4 hours from NYC, making it a fantastic weekend getaway, especially in the fall!
If you’re looking for a weekend filled with history, unexpected discoveries, great food, and a little mystery, ADD GETTYSBURG TO YOUR LIST! ❤️
Looking for more fall escapes from the city?
Don’t miss my Catskills fall foliage day and the Circle Line Bear Mountain fall cruise.
Staying in the city for Halloween? Here’s everything you need to know about the NYC Village Halloween Parade.
